Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Fed adopts de facto inflation target

Most news headlines, it looks like, have focused on the dissent of views about the launch of QE2 in minutes of the latest FOMC meeting. But what's more revealing is that the Fed discussed whether or not to adopt an inflation targeting, which Chairman Ben Bernanke once promoted but has withdrawn since getting the Fed job.

No decision was made on the adoption of "a numerical inflation objective or a target path for the price level" at this time, but instead the projected longer-run PCE inflation rate in the Summary of Economic Projection is left as a de facto inflation target, saying
participants noted that the longer-run projections contained in the Summary of Economic Projections, which is released once per quarter in conjunction with the minutes of four of the Committee's meetings, convey considerable information about participants' assessments of their statutory objectives.
The Fed implicitly acknowledges that its monetary policy, be it quantitative easing or rate change, is supposed to run for this goal, now 1.6-2.0%, which has just been revised down from 1.7-2.0% in June. PCE inflation rate is currently around 1.4%, a little bit lower from the target.

This de facto inflation target resembles that of the BoJ. Instead of the longer-run PCE inflation rate projection, Japan's central bank has "Understanding of Medium- to Long-Term Price Stability," which was introduced in 2006 to clarify the meaning of price stability in a mid- to long-term as an objective of monetary policy. According to the BoJ,
In today's Monetary Policy Meeting, there was a discussion of the level of inflation rate that each Policy Board member currently understands as price stability from a medium- to long-term viewpoint, in the conduct of monetary policy ("an understanding of medium- to long-term price stability"). While there was a range of views, reflecting the differences in the relative weight attached to factors affecting the understanding of price stability, it was recognized that the level was somewhat lower than that in major overseas economies. It was agreed that, by making use of the rate of year-on-year change in the consumer price index to describe the understanding, an approximate range between zero and two percent was generally consistent with the distribution of each Board member's understanding of medium- to long-term price stability. Most Board members' median figures fell on both sides of one percent. Given that the understanding of medium- to long-term price stability may change gradually reflecting developments such as structural changes in the economy, as a rule, Board members will review it annually.
Currently, the average of most Policy Board members' "understanding" is around 1% in terms of the year-over-year increase rate of CPI. The BoJ hasn't officially declared the adoption of an inflation target mechanism, but a 1% change of CPI is widely believed to be no less than the BoJ's price target. The latest figure is -0.6%, which means Japan is still mired in deflation and hence the central bank will continue the current monetary loosing.

The Fed has, on the other hand, one more target: unemployment rate. The longer-run unemployment rate is projected to be 5.0-6.0%, which has recently been changed from 5.0-5.3% in June, reflecting severe labor markets condition where the current unemployment rate is as much as 9.6%.

As is well known, the Fed has dual mandate: price stability and maximum employment. So, the question may arise as to what if one mandate is fulfilled while the other isn't. Stagflation, recession with rising inflation, is the prime example which could compromise the Fed's mission. As far as the recent minutes go, it seems that the Fed has much more fear of deflation than stagflation.

Lastly, some FOMC members raised concern that "additional expansion of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet could put unwanted downward pressure on the dollar's value in foreign exchange markets." As my previous post shows, Bernanke rebutted a claim that the Fed's quantitative easing has weakened the dollar. But now it's clear that some noticed a positive relation between the monetary easing and a cheap dollar, which would be a cause of later controversy on the Fed's role.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

The world according to BoJ

Bank of Japan Governor Masaaki Shirakawa made two very interesting comments on economic policy. The first one is on the objective of Japanese monetary policy.
Bank of Japan Governor Masaaki Shirakawa said on Friday the central bank's view on the price outlook was in sync with that of the government.

But Shirakawa said monetary policy should not be guided just by looking at price moves.

"Monetary policy should not be implemented just by looking at prices. We need to look at the overall balance of the economy," he told an upper house budget committee meeting.
Be careful that he maintains, "Monetary policy should not be implemented just by looking at prices. We need to look at the overall balance of the economy."

Is it strange or incorrect in light of the BoJ's objective? Of course, not.
The Act (note: the Bank of Japan Act) also stipulates the Bank's principle of currency and monetary control as follows: "currency and monetary control by the Bank of Japan shall be aimed at achieving price stability, thereby contributing to the sound development of the national economy."
We acknowledge that one of the BoJ's objectives is "the sound development of the national economy." It should be no problem, then, that the Governor underscores "the overall balance of the economy" to steer monetary policy.

But the BoJ moved forward its monetary policy meeting to November 4-5, which was originally scheduled for November 15-16, because it can initiate an additional program right after the Fed's FOMC meeting in November 2-3 if the yen surges enough to hamper the economy. Shirakawa denied that overseas events are factored in for the date change, but it's highly likely that the BoJ has weighed in favor of currency policy given that the policy interest rate is near zero.

So, Shirakawa's true intention looks like that Japanese monetary policy is aimed not for rate change anymore but to guide the yen as low as possible, which is in tandem with the government's initiative. That's why he emphasized "the overall balance of the economy" to conduct monetary policy. It's not clear whether this is a departure from the traditional monetary policy, but we should be advised that the BoJ's eye is now kept on currency markets, not bond markets anymore.

Regarding to that, the English article's title "BOJ Shirakawa: BOJ's price views in syc with govt" is a little bit off the point. The title of the original Japanese version "No central banks implement monetary policy just by looking at prices in the short term" seems more in tune with his inner message.

The other comment is on international currency system. Shirakawa said at an upper house budget committee meeting,
Both of developed and emerging nations must realize that the effect of monetary and currency policy returns to their own after spreading to other countries.
I haven't found an English version, which implies that nobody in the world has paid any attention to this comment. It looks like a very, very, very polite criticism by a too-well-behaved central banker of US and Chinese policy.

Labels:

Monday, November 08, 2010

Inflation says it all

To rise or not to rise, that is the question.

A streak of the central banks' meeting last week signaled the age of divergence to achieve the desirable path to price stability. Among four of the largest economies' central banks, the Fed, the ECB, the BoJ, and the BoE, which discussed the course of monetary policy amid a weak recovery, only the Fed loosened its grip on monetary policy to start buying long-term Treasury securities, dubbed QE2, as widely expected. The other three central banks, which convened after the FOMC meeting, kept their stance, though the BoJ decided last month to pump more money into the economy by purchasing JGB, REIT, and corporate bonds.


What split their responses? Just look at inflation, and you'll have a clear reason behind it. CPI inflation rate in the UK and Euro zone, whose central banks didn't move, is higher than the US and Japan, both of which resumed printing money.

Let's see how they think about inflation. The FOMC statement declares that measures of underlying inflation are somewhat low, relative to levels that the Committee judges to be consistent, over the longer run. The Fed's Chairman Ben Bernanke, of course, hasn't forgotten the mandate of the central bank as holding inflation at a low level.
"We are absolutely committed to keeping inflation low and stable," Bernanke said in response to a question at Jacksonville University. "We have the tools to unwind and tighten policy at the appropriate time, when that time comes."
All the more important right now is, however, to keep deflation at bay.
"We're not in the business of trying to create inflation, our purpose is to provide additional stimulus to help the economy recover and to avoid potentially additional disinflation, which I think we all agree could also be worrisome."
...
"We've had a very significant disinflation since the beginning of the crisis. We should not be satisfied with a situation where we have both a large amount of slack on the employment side and inflation which is below our generally agreed upon level and seems to be declining over time."
The ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet, on the other hand, described risks to the inflation outlook as "slightly tilted to the upside," and even reiterated his intention to stick to an exit strategy, saying "the non-standard measures that we have taken are, by definition, of a transitory nature."

Thus, views on the outlook of inflation are one of the main drivers which divided the major central banks' reaction to the current economy last week.

Meanwhile, German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble wasn't patient enough to contain his complaint on the Fed's policy.
"I have great doubts about whether it makes sense to pump unlimited amounts of money into the markets," Schaeuble told Der Spiegel news magazine. "There is no shortage of liquidity in the U.S. economy. I can't see the economic argument for this move."
The U.S. central bank's decision to extend its program of quantitative easing raised uncertainty in the world economy, he said.
"It will make it difficult to get a reasonable balance between the industrial and emerging nations and it undermines the credibility of U.S. financial policy," Schaeuble said.
He has repeatedly criticized the U.S. plan to buy debt and pump more money into the economy to prop it up. He also defended Germany against criticism of its trade surplus.
"The German export success is not due to any currency tricks but rather due to the improved competitiveness of German companies," Schaeuble said. "The American growth model is stuck in a deep crisis."The United States has lived beyond its means for too long, its financial sector is disproportionally inflated and its industrial core neglected. There are many reasons for America's problems ... the German export surplus is not one of them."
Schaeuble also criticized U.S. foreign exchange policy. "It's not right when the Americans accuse China of manipulating exchange rates and then push the dollar exchange rate lower by opening up the flood gates by turning on the printing presses," he said.
On Friday he said U.S. monetary policy was "clueless."
German Finance Minister was also reported to liken the Fed's quantitative easing to China's currency policy.
"At the moment, from a European viewpoint, one could get the impression that the U.S. is doing through other means what it is reproaching China for," Schaeuble said at a conference in Berlin.
"One could get the idea that the instruments are different but the goal is the same, and the one who suffers are clearly...to a certain degree the Europeans," the minister argued.
Well, Germans definitely have something to worry.

The Japanese, in turn, seems like too well-behaved to raise a concern, despite the yen's sharp appreciation. Japanese Finance Minister Yoshihiko Noda made no comment when asked about the Federal Reserve's latest monetary easing, though admitting to have to closely watch the US economy and monetary policy (in Japanese). The BoJ Governor Masaaki Shirakawa dismissed the idea of monetary easing race, saying "I do not see Japan and the United States as in a monetary easing competition."

Bernanke rebutted critics who claim that the Fed's monetary policy has given birth to the weak dollar.
"The best fundamentals for the dollar will come when the economy is growing strongly," Bernanke said today in response to questions from college students in Jacksonville, Florida. "That is where the fundamentals come from. We are aware the dollar plays a special role in the global economy."
"A strong U.S. economy is critical not just for Americans but for a global recovery," he added. "So in that respect it is very important we do achieve a faster recovery in the U.S."
Surprised, NYT wrote, "In commenting on the dollar, Mr. Bernanke was making an unusual departure from custom. By tradition, the dollar is the purview of the Treasury secretary and monetary policy is the domain of the Fed chairman, and neither official steps on the other's turf."

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, November 04, 2010

Bank of Japanization of Fed

My capacity of English severely constrains how to make up a new word, but it seems to me that the Fed is clearly going to follow after the BoJ, in the sense that the next move would be nothing less than the de-facto inflation targeting where the BoJ is on the way.

At the FOMC meeting, the Fed decided to buy $75 billion of long-term Treasury securities per month by the end of June in 2011, which totals $600 billion. At the time of QE1, the Fed purchased $300 billion over 6 months. The magnitude and term of QE2 is at least larger than QE1.

A little bit interesting to me is that the Fed will keep reinvesting principal payments from its securities holdings. The Fed is now buying about $30 billion of long-term Treasury securities per month as a reinvestment of principal payments. It's not much compared with the new purchase, but the Fed's intention would be that there is no reason to stop it right now.

It would be better to gauge the impact of the mid-term election, where the Democrats were heavily blown, on the economy, but it's beyond my ability. My guess is that the congress will be so paralyzed that the next big push from fiscal arena is difficult to be taken into account as a reliable and expected economic policy. So, the next Fed's move would be far bolder and greater than thought to make up for fiscal inability.

If the Bank of Japanization means the incompetence of monetary policy, what would be left to stimulate the economy? Could paralyzed congress save the country? The US seems to be getting into a very, very hard time.

Labels: , ,

Friday, October 29, 2010

BoJ's cause

Nobody expected anything important to be announced at the Bank of Japan's monetary policy meeting yesterday, but one thing looks like worth mentioning. The BoJ, as expected, held its key policy interest rates unchanged at 0 to 0.1%, and unveiled the details of "comprehensive monetary easing" put forth in early October, including the purchase of low-graded corporate bonds.

One has to notice, however, that the Japanese central bank moved up its next meeting to November 4-5, which was originally scheduled to be held in November 15-16. The BoJ said the reason for change is "to discuss and decide the principal terms and conditions for the purchases of ETFs and J-REITs with a view to promptly starting their purchases." But given that the Fed is likely to start QE2 at the FOMC meeting in November 2-3, it should be read that the BoJ's true intention is to make a quick response to prevent the yen from appreciating further after the Fed's additional monetary policy easing, probably adding another round of bond purchase.

Coincidentally, both the Bank of England and European Central Bank will announce the result of their monetary policy meeting in November 4. But their position is different from the BoJ's, and they wouldn't consider the Fed's policy as too critical to be factored in their monetary policy decisions.

First, Britain's third quarter GDP beat market expectations by a wide margin, and S&P has just changed its outlook for Britain's long-term sovereign bond from negative to stable, which by no means hastens the BoE's policy change at this time.

Second, Germany is estimated to grow by more than 3% this year due to weak euro, placing itself as one of the fastest growing economies among rich nations. The ECB would feel content as Europe's largest economy is in a good shape, though having fiscally feeble countries like PIIGS yet.

BoJ's cause, though covert, is distinct from its peers in that it has to take strengthening currency as detrimental to a deflation-riddled, debt-overloaded and export-dependent country.

Labels: ,

Saturday, October 23, 2010

Future debate on monetary policy

It seems like the graph below is spreading in the econ-blogosphere. I took it from here. You can also see it here and here. The idea is simple: the US is falling into deflation like Japan.


Yup. It could be.

One might wonder how to avoid deflation, the worst case scenario for all policy makers in the current world. According to the Federal Reserve Act, the Board of Governors and the Federal Open Market Committee should seek "to promote effectively the goals of maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates." So, the Fed is expected to act against deflation in the US. But should disinflation go on or turn to deflation, discussion would be sharply divided by two on how to do with monetary policy. I call the two "Enough" and "Not enough."

"Enough" camp refers to those who think that monetary policy isn't effective to combat deflation. Most central bankers would belong to this group if they see deflation entrenched despite every policy they make. Central bankers contrive some policy action more often than not at a monetary policy meeting, but they admit that it's no use to relieve the pain. Monetary policy would gradually turn to an excuse for dodging criticism from the parliament which is worried about reelection. They think that fiscal policy or structural reform or combination of both should be much more conductive to shore up the economy. Some of this camp preach more radical reforms like "Any monetary or fiscal policy won't work. Complete restructuring of the whole economy is the only way to survive." But it's not so many.

"Not enough" people are likely to regard deflation as the result of hesitation or inaction by central bankers which they think should give priority to price stability. Analysts or economists in private institutions would be eager to join this group. Whenever central bankers move, they think that it's not enough to root out deflation. Unless deflation is out of sight, they keep saying "It's not enough!", and accusing central bankers of their inertia or even lack of knowledge in basic economics. This group wants central bankers to buy every financial assets, no matter which is stocks, bonds, or REIT, and to degrade central bank's assets. One of the characters of this circle is to almost deny the independence of central banking and to promote the integration of monetary and fiscal policy.

Which party would you think you join?

Labels: ,

Wednesday, October 06, 2010

BOJ as Mrs. Watanabe

Today, everybody is talking about BOJ's policy. As I noted yesterday, it should result in vain to bear any fruit in reviving Japan's ailing economy. Politicians touted it as "decisive", but what matters to BOJ is how decisive it looks. The more decisive it looks and the more people talk about it, the more pressure BOJ hopes politicians feel to act, thus evading further criticism from politicians including whether BOJ should play a sole role as a monetary policy steward. It doesn't matter whether it actually works or not.

We also have to notice that BOJ's main target this time is not bond markets or even banks. They are focusing on the currency markets. BOJ has already abandoned any efforts to influence bank lending through bond markets. There has been no monetary policy in Japan since the dawn of this century.

Japan intervened in the currency markets to lower Yen last month. It looks like there have been few effects so far. US dollar is traded now at 83.2 Yen. It's a little bit higher than 82 Yen which Japan intervened last time. Given that US is betting on the weak currency and beginning QE2, it would be very difficult to turn the trend around.

IMF chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn is quoted as warning on the looming currency war among nations.
Countries risk undermining the global economic recovery if they use their currencies to try to boost domestic growth, the head of the International Monetary Fund warned on Tuesday in a newspaper interview.

IMF Managing Director Dominique Strauss-Kahn made the comments ahead of the fund's October8-10 annual meeting in which currency depreciations by governments to boost exports will be a key issue.

"There is clearly the idea beginning to circulate that currencies can be used as a policy weapon," Dominique Strauss-Kahn said in comments published on the FT website on Tuesday.

"Translated into action, such an idea would represent a very serious risk to the global recovery... Any such approach would have a negative and very damaging longer-run impact," he said.

Brazil, whose finance minister has warned of an international "currency war," on Monday doubled a tax on foreign investors buying local bonds to 4 percent to curb a strong real, boosted by high domestic interest rates and a commodity boom.

"We have seen reports that some emerging countries whose economies face big capital inflows are saying that maybe it is time to use their currencies to try to gain an advantage, particularly on the trade side," Strauss-Kahn said.

"I don't think that is a good solution."
He is right to be concerned about the currency battle under way among major countries. The currency war has been a major subject of worry in the circle of notable economists like Michael Pettis. Three largest creditor countries, namely China, Japan, and Germany, should act as an anchor to underpin the world economy by propping up, not holding down, domestic demand.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, October 05, 2010

BOJ cut interest rates

BOJ unexpectedly cut the interest rates from around 0.1% to 0.0-0.1%, and decided to buy 3.5 trillion yen of government debts in today's monetary policy meeting. The markets reacted strongly to this news.

I'm sure that nobody believes this is going to mend Japan's chronicle deflation. BOJ only meant, "We did something, so the ball has been passed on to politicians to tackle the problem." Then, what are politicians going to do? Another round of fiscal expansion? Where is a revenue source? More debt issue?

All has been well heard in the last 20 years. The same policy, the same result. And nothing happened.

Labels: ,